Best Vanilla Ice Cream for Root Beer Floats

Craving that perfect root beer float? The choice of vanilla ice cream is crucial. We’ve researched the top vanilla ice creams to pair with your bubbly root beer. Here’s the scoop.

Top 5 Best Vanilla Ice Cream for Root Beer Floats

1. Breyers Classics Ice Cream

Price – $6.69

Ratings – 4.7 out of 5

Made with 100% Grade A Milk & Cream, Breyers Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream stands out with its quality ingredients, including sustainable Rainforest Alliance Certified vanilla beans.

Pros and Cons

Rich creamy texture.

Sustainable vanilla.

Great for coffee mix-ins.
Not very strong vanilla flavor.

Packaging issues in delivery.


A delight for eco-conscious consumers, Breyers offers a creamy texture combined with sustainable sourcing. The subtlety of vanilla makes it a versatile choice, ensuring it complements, rather than overpowers, your root beer.

2. Happy Belly French Vanilla Ice Cream

Price – $3.39

Ratings – 4.5 out of 5

An Amazon brand, Happy Belly offers a French vanilla flavor inspired by traditional French custard.

Pros and Cons

Old-fashioned flavor.

Rich and creamy.

Improved flavor over time.
Less creamy compared to some brands.

Not as high quality as expected.


Capturing the essence of traditional French custard, Happy Belly promises an old-fashioned flavor at an accessible price point. It’s a nostalgic trip to the local ice cream parlor from the comfort of your home.

3. Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Price – $7.49

Ratings – 4.5 out of 5

Spotlighting a rich vanilla flavor with vanilla bean specs, this ice cream promises a delightful experience.

Pros and Cons

Best Vanilla Bean flavor.

Great value for the price.
Tastes like freezer burn.


For those seeking an authentic vanilla bean experience, this ice cream stands out with visible vanilla specks and a rich flavor profile. A delightful choice for the purists who savor genuine vanilla bean goodness.

4. 365 by Whole Foods Market, Vanilla Bean Organic

Price – $4.79

Ratings – 4.5 out of 5

This organic offering by Whole Foods promises a dance-down-the-aisles feeling with its flavors.

Pros and Cons

Smooth and flavorful.

Right level of sweetness.
Unusual color due to annatto.

Just average in taste.


An organic treat that doesn’t skimp on flavor. With its perfect balance of sweetness and smooth texture, it’s a premium choice for the health-conscious gourmet.

5. Rich Vanilla Ice Cream

Price – $6.39

Ratings 4.7 out of 5

With real crushed vanilla bean seeds, this option is creamy and delicious, living up to its promise of being “anything but vanilla”.

Pros and Cons

Old fashioned ice cream shop flavor.

Smooth texture.
Can be too heavy and sweet for some.


Living up to its name, this rich vanilla option, sprinkled with real vanilla bean seeds, offers a classic taste reminiscent of traditional ice cream shops. A choice that elevates any root beer float to gourmet status.

Which is the Best Option?

In terms of sustainability, flavor, and creaminess, Breyers Classics Ice Cream seems to take the cake. Its commitment to sustainable sourcing and the creamy texture make it perfect for root beer floats. However, taste is subjective and everyone’s float boat is different! So, choose what floats your boat and enjoy every sip and bite!

Boost your float’s flavor with the best root beer extract.

Shaleen Ashish
About the author

Leave a Comment