Find the best pan pizza in Chicago

We all have been fans of thin-crust pizzas, but the classic and old-school pan pizzas will always be our forever favorite. If you are hunting for places that serve pan pizzas in Chicago, you are at the right place. This article has covered some of the best places in the Chicago region specializing in pan pizzas.

Best pan pizza in Chicago

Check out these places for the best pan pizzas in town:

1. Pequod’s Pizza

Pequod’s Pizza has been in the business for nearly 40 years and tops the list of best pan pizza restaurants in Chicago. Its location near the famous Lincoln Park neighborhood makes it even more accessible to locals and tourists. What makes them unique is their pan-style deep-dish Pizza with a caramelized crust, which has made them a staple choice in the nearby areas. The four sizes of pan pizzas available at Pequod’s Pizza are personal (7 inches), small (10 inches), medium (12 inches), and large (14 inches).

Timings: Monday to Saturday – 11 a.m. until 2 a.m.

Address: 2207 N Clybourn Ave, Chicago, IL 60614, United States

User Reviews for Pequod’s Pizza

Positive ReviewNegative Review
“The caramelized crust is to die for!”“Wish they had more vegetarian options.”
“Best pizza in Lincoln Park!”“The wait time can be long during peak hours.”
“Friendly staff and cozy ambiance.”“Parking can be a challenge.”
“Generous toppings and perfect cheese blend.”“Can be a bit pricey compared to others.”

2. Milly’s Pizza In The Pan

pan pizza

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan was opened in 2020 by Robert Maleksi as a tribute to his grandmother, who taught him cooking. Even though the restaurant is not as old as its counterparts, its preparation will surely make you their fan. The two sizes available here are 10 inches and 14 inches. And their USP is fresher ingredients and quality preparation. Although they have a limited menu, we are sure you will find something that will excite your taste buds.

Timings: Wednesday to Saturday – 4 p.m. to 9 p.m.; Sunday – 4 p.m. to 8 p.m.

Address: 1005 W Argyle St, Chicago, IL 60640, United States.

User Reviews for Milly’s Pizza In The Pan

Positive ReviewNegative Review
“Fresh ingredients make all the difference!”“Limited menu options.”
“A hidden gem in Chicago.”“Can get crowded during weekends.”
“Love their thin crust options too.”“Wish they had more locations.”
“Perfect for family dinners.”“Sometimes there’s a long wait for delivery.”

3. My Pi Pizza

My Pi Pizza takes pride in its family-owned recipes that have been tried and tested for 40 years. They use a unique tomato sauce made with fresh ingredients and vine-ripened San Marzano tomatoes that gives their pizzas a unique taste. My Pi Pizza’s Unique Pizza in the pan comes in three sizes, small (9 inches), medium (12 inches), and large (14 inches).

Timings: Monday to Sunday – 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.

Address: 2010 N Damen Avenue Unit E, Chicago, IL 60647.

User Reviews for My Pi Pizza

Positive ReviewNegative Review
“The tomato sauce is rich and flavorful!”“The crust can be a bit too thick for my liking.”
“Love the family-friendly vibe.”“They sometimes run out of popular toppings.”
“Consistent quality every time.”“Delivery times can be inconsistent.”
“Great value for money.”“Wish they had more vegan options.”

4. The Art of Pizza

The Art of Pizza prioritizes customer satisfaction by providing them with pizzas made from fresh ingredients and excellent service. They have an expansive menu comprising thin crust, pan, and stuffed pizzas, apart from a great range of appetizers.

Timings: Monday to Sunday – 10.50 a.m. to 10.30 p.m.

Address: 3033 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60657 3.

User Reviews for The Art of Pizza

Positive ReviewNegative Review
“A wide variety of pizzas to choose from!”“The ambiance could use some updating.”
“Stuffed pizzas are a must-try.”“Can get quite crowded on weekends.”
“Friendly staff and quick service.”“Some pizzas can be a bit greasy.”
“Great for both dine-in and takeout.”“Wish they had more gluten-free options.”

5. Giordano’s

Claiming to be Chicago’s best Pizza since 1970, Giordano’s is one pizzeria that employs six trained artisans to build pizzas according to customers’ likes and preferences. Their fluffy Wisconsin mozzarella and fresh topics will genuinely make you believe why they are the best in the business. Do not forget to try their signature parmesan-crusted pan pizza, topped with their legendary sauce, which is available in two sizes, small (10 inches) and medium (12 inches).

Timings: Monday to Sunday – 10 a.m. to 11 p.m.

Address: 223 W Jackson Blvd, Chicago, IL 60606, United States.

User Reviews for Giordano’s

Positive ReviewNegative Review
“The parmesan-crusted pan pizza is heavenly!”“The wait can be long, especially during dinner hours.”
“Perfect balance of cheese and toppings.”“The interior can feel a bit cramped.”
“A true Chicago pizza experience.”“Prices are on the higher side.”
“Great location and easy to access.”“Sometimes there’s inconsistency in pizza sizes.”

Which is the Best Option?

Considering the legacy, unique offerings, and consistent positive reviews, Pequod’s Pizza stands out as the top choice for pan pizza in Chicago. Their caramelized crust and diverse size options cater to every pizza lover’s preference.


We hope this article helped all pizza lovers find some of the best pan pizzas in Chicago. Try these out and let us know about your experience in the comment below.

Stay tuned for more reviews, queries, and informational content!

Once you’ve tasted the best pan pizza in Chicago, don’t forget to try the best Chicago style pizza in town.

Shaleen Ashish
About the author

Leave a Comment