Root beer, a timeless beverage, evokes memories of family gatherings, sunny afternoons, and the sheer joy of sipping a frosty mug. Its unique flavor is unmatched, and the essence of this beverage lies in its extract. For culinary enthusiasts and DIY soda makers, finding the perfect root beer extract is paramount. With a plethora of options in the market, we’ve streamlined the search for you. Dive in as we explore the top root beer extracts, weighing their pros and cons, to help you make an informed decision.
Top 5 Root Beer Extracts
1. Cook’s Choice Root Beer Extract
Price – $7.37
Ratings – 4.2 out of 5
Description
Cook’s Choice brings an old-fashioned style Root Beer Extract enriched with Pure Vanilla Extract. Perfect for a variety of recipes like homemade root beer, ice cream, popsicles, and even cakes. Available in sizes from 4 oz. to 32 oz, the product is housed in a resealable amber glass jar. Key features:
- Creamy, nostalgic, and sweet flavor
- Gluten-free, non-GMO, Allergen Free, Vegan and Kosher
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Great root beer flavor, contains vanilla, well-packed | Issues with packaging seal |
Verdict:
Cook’s Choice stands out with its authentic old-fashioned style. Its rich blend with Pure Vanilla Extract makes it versatile for various culinary ventures. The flavor strikes the right chord between creamy and nostalgic, and the amber glass jar packaging not only enhances the aesthetic but ensures safe and convenient storage. The product’s commitment to being gluten-free, non-GMO, allergen-free, vegan, and kosher adds to its appeal.
2. LorAnn Root Beer SS Flavor (4-ounce bottle)
Price – $18.92
Ratings – 4.6 out of 5
Description :
LorAnn presents a unique root beer flavor that reminds many of a nostalgic summer day or candy from Grandma’s purse. It’s a robust mix of vanilla, molasses, licorice, and anise. Given its super strength, a little goes a long way!
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Delicious in lattes, great for making hard candy | Contains propylene glycol |
Verdict:
Lor Ann’s super-strength root beer flavor is a powerful rendition of the classic. It’s a harmonious mix of vanilla, molasses, licorice, and anise, making it delightful and distinct. The extract’s strength means you get value for your money, as a little goes a long way. Whether for baking, candy-making, or even lattes, its versatility shines.
3. Brewer’s Best Classic Soda Extract Root Beer
Price – $78.70
Ratings – 3.5 out of 5
Description :
A caffeine and gluten-free root beer extract from Brewer’s Best. It comes in individually boxed 2 oz. bottles.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Good flavor. | Large Size. |
Verdict:
Brewer’s Best offers a root beer extract that is both caffeine and gluten-free, making it a favorable choice for health-conscious consumers. The packaging is in 2 oz. bottles ensure ease of use. For those who like their root beer pure and traditional, Brewer’s Best is a top contender.
4. LorAnn Root Beer SS Flavor (1 dram bottle)
Price – $4.75
Ratings – 4.6 out of 5
Description
LorAnn’s super strength root beer flavor, reminiscent of the golden days, comes in a small dram size, perfect for a batch of homemade hard-tack candy. Also available in larger sizes for those who want more.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| True root beer flavor, great for baking and ice cream | Contains undesirable ingredients not initially listed |
Verdict:
The strength and flavor of LorAnn are consistent even in this smaller packaging. It captures the essence of the old-fashioned root beer with the right notes of vanilla, molasses, licorice, and anise. Ideal for those looking to experiment or for small-batch creations, its convenience and potent flavor make it a favorite.
5. Shank’s Root Beer Extract
Price – $8.22
Ratings – 4.5 out of 5
Description
Shank’s Root Beer Extract offers a versatile flavor, perfect for a wide range of recipes, from beverages to baked goods to frozen desserts.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Satisfying taste, ideal for sugar-free drinks Perfect for root beer flavored ice cream | Needs seltzer for certain applications |
Verdict:
Shank’s offers a versatile root beer flavor that’s perfect for an array of culinary adventures. From beverages to baked goods, it adds a burst of authentic root beer taste. Especially notable is its ability to cater to sugar-free preferences, making it a preferred choice for those seeking healthier alternatives without compromising on flavor.
Which is the Best Option?
When choosing the best root beer extract, your preference depends on its intended use. If you prioritize natural ingredients, Cook’s Choice stands out. For super strength and versatile usage, LorAnn’s offerings are compelling, though one must be wary of undisclosed ingredients. Those keen on gluten-free options might opt for Brewer’s Best. Shank’s offers a delightful taste that’s versatile across multiple recipes. Weigh the pros and cons, and decide the best fit for your culinary needs!
Utilize our top-rated extract when you make old-fashioned homemade root beer.
